Home Business Insights Others Old goods are supporting a trillion-yuan market: what is driving secondhand consumption growth?

Old goods are supporting a trillion-yuan market: what is driving secondhand consumption growth?

Views:17
By DJyanbao on 2026-10-21
Tags:
secondhand consumption
circular economy
consumer behavior

A new shopping option is emerging at malls: buying secondhand.

In the Hubo area of Shanghai Hongqiao Tiandi, brands such as Shizhi Transparent Warehouse, Zhuanzhuayu, and Green Cycle Store have clustered together, forming a commercial district with a circular-consumption character. During the 2026 National Day holiday, Super Zhuanzhuan’s Shanghai flagship store opened for trial operation, covering more than 6,000 square meters and offering 50,000 items. From a single store to an entire district, secondhand goods are entering a more complete offline consumption scene.

 

Behind the changes in stores, a more important question is worth studying: how do consumers decide how much an old item is still worth? And how many steps must a product go through before it moves from one person’s unused possession to another person’s need?

These two questions connect supply and demand in the secondhand market, and they also determine whether secondhand stores can evolve from a novel shopping option into a sustainable business.

01 Consumers are beginning to recalculate what is “worth it”

When we buy something, what exactly are we paying for?

It may be functionality, quality, or design; it may also be brand, scarcity, and the satisfaction of owning it. Secondhand transactions create room to recombine these values: consumers can accept some signs of use in exchange for a more suitable price, or actively search for pre-owned items because a style has already been discontinued.

This choice reflects a state in which practical needs and interest-driven consumption coexist.

The China Internet Network Information Center’s Digital Consumption Development Report (2025) shows that 67.1% of online shoppers prioritize “practicality” when choosing substitute products, while 60.6% prioritize “self-pleasing” and pay for interests and emotions. These two figures describe the overall population of online shoppers, but they provide a backdrop for understanding secondhand consumption: budget control and personal preference can happen at the same time.

Specialized research on secondhand 3C products explains this choice more concretely.

The Trust Compounding Effect: Insights into Consumer Trends in the Back-to-School Secondhand 3C Market, jointly released by JD and NielsenIQ, shows that in the survey for the report, 34% of consumers agreed that buying secondhand can reduce decision-making and trial-and-error costs, and 29% used secondhand products to experience different products. These findings apply to the report’s secondhand 3C sample and cannot be directly extended to all secondhand categories.

Why Buy? Consumer Attitudes

Buying second-hand 3C products is a rational decision that combines quality and cost-effectiveness.

Category / SectionContent / Data
Main ConceptThe Return of "Value-ism": Rationally Reshaping Consumption Boundaries
Background & Shift• Changes in the economic environment have caused large expenditures to be re-examined.
• Consumption concepts have shifted from "chasing the new" to "making smart decisions."
• Standardized operations of second-hand platforms make transactions transparent and trustworthy.
• Therefore, second-hand is no longer a compromise, but a rational decision combining quality and cost-effectiveness.
Consumer Views on Second-hand 3C Products01. Buying second-hand reduces decision-making and trial-and-error costs (34%)
02. Getting a highly cost-effective second-hand item gives me a sense of accomplishment (33%)
03. Second-hand is more often used to experience different products (29%)
User Quote"When my sophomore major courses started, the requirements for computers were very high. High-performance laptops costing 7-8K or even over 10K were a bit difficult for me... I worked during the summer vacation of my freshman year and earned 2,500, and bought a second-hand laptop with half the performance of a brand new one." — Li, a college student in Beijing
(Source: NielsenIQ)

This means the appeal of secondhand consumption lies not only in saving money, but also in lowering the barrier to trying a new need.

For example, for someone just starting to explore photography, a secondhand camera that meets functional needs can reduce the cost of entering the hobby; for someone who temporarily needs mobile office equipment, a secondhand computer can meet short-term usage needs; for collectors, the value of a discontinued item does not necessarily decline simply because it has been used longer.

The same product may no longer be needed by one person, yet be exactly what another person has just begun to need. Different requirements for functionality, style, and usage time create room for a second transaction.

Therefore, studying the secondhand market requires looking at consumers’ price sensitivity together with their judgment of product value.

The opportunity in the secondhand market comes from the fact that the same item has different value in different hands.

02 Beyond low prices, there is also a ledger of concerns

An attractive price does not necessarily lead to a transaction.

Consumers also consider whether the product has functional problems, whether defects have been concealed, what “90% new” actually means, and whether disputes can be resolved if they arise.

A public excerpt from the 2025–2026 China Secondhand E-commerce Industry Development and Consumer Behavior Survey Data shows that in its 2025 consumer survey, 64.71% of respondents paid attention to seller reputation when transacting, and 44.68% focused on whether the price was reasonable. This reflects the transaction experience of the survey sample and should not be interpreted as the proportion of transactions across the entire market.

New products help consumers judge through standardized models, specifications, and brand promises, while secondhand goods come with usage history. Even if the model is the same, two products may differ significantly in repair history, battery condition, and exterior wear.

These differences create a cost that is not easy to see directly: the time spent repeatedly asking questions, checking photos, comparing condition, and handling disputes after receiving the goods.

The above-mentioned JD and NielsenIQ report lists product and information authenticity, transaction efficiency and cost, and after-sales service as barriers to secondhand transactions; it also discusses consumers’ attention to battery health, repair/disassembly history, and major defects.

Obstacles in Second-hand Transactions

Top 5 Obstacles in Second-hand Transactions

Obstacle FactorPercentage
Authenticity of goods and information63%
Transaction efficiency and cost63%
After-sales and service experience58%
Reliability of platform and rules53%
Offline services and physical support38%
(Source: NielsenIQ)

From the perspective of consumer decision-making, the actual purchase cost of secondhand goods should take into account the transaction price, time investment, and potential losses. If a lower-priced item requires too much uncertainty, its appeal will also decline.

This is also why offline spaces can add value. In-person experience helps consumers confirm appearance, size, and feel of use; inspection reports and clear after-sales terms further supplement information that cannot be judged by the eye alone.

But the existence of a store does not automatically mean trust has been established. Even after seeing the product in person, consumers may still be unable to judge internal repairs, hidden faults, or remaining service life. What is truly useful is connecting physical experience, product descriptions, and after-sales responsibility.

Consumers may be willing to accept signs of use, but transaction information still needs to be clear and complete.

03 Selling unused items is also a form of demand

To understand secondhand consumption, we also need to stand on the seller’s side.

Old phones, unused clothes, and sports equipment no longer in use may still have value, but selling them requires taking photos, writing descriptions, setting prices, replying to messages, and arranging delivery.

Pricing is especially difficult: the original price can be checked, but it is hard to answer directly how much discount the item should take based on its current condition.

The same survey by iiMedia Research shows that when respondents sold secondhand goods, 58.49% encountered problems such as inconsistent pricing for similar items, difficulty in setting a price, and being easily haggled down. This reflects the transaction experience of the survey sample and should not be understood as the proportion of transactions across the entire market.

From this perspective, demand on the supply side includes both the selling price and disposal efficiency.

Some people are willing to wait slowly for the right buyer in order to secure a better price; others want to free up space quickly and value saving time and effort more. Different preferences correspond to different services such as peer-to-peer transactions, consignment, and platform buyback.

Transaction Methods

Transaction MethodWhat the Seller GetsWho Undertakes the Main Follow-up Work
Direct personal transactionMore autonomous pricing spaceThe seller handles communication, delivery, and dispute resolution independently
ConsignmentDisplay, sales, and transaction assistanceThe operator undertakes agreed services; selling time remains uncertain
Buyout recyclingFaster disposal and payment collectionThe operator bears subsequent inventory and sales risks

(Source: public industry data, compiled by Dongjian Research)

Here it is necessary to distinguish between who handles the transaction and who owns the product; these are two different things. Peer-to-peer transactions are not the same as consignment, and platform involvement does not necessarily mean the platform buys the item outright first. Whether revenue comes from service fees, commissions, or the spread between purchase and resale depends on the actual business arrangement.

For operators, reducing the seller’s disposal burden also increases their own workload. Replacing the seller in inspection, communication, storage, and buyer search requires corresponding revenue to cover the cost.

 

Therefore, when evaluating whether a buyback price is reasonable, it is not enough to look only at the gap between it and the final retail price. One must also examine whether the inspection basis, deduction items, and charging method are clear, and whether the seller understands the service they have chosen.

Whether the industry chain can continue to secure supply depends on whether sellers feel the price is understandable and the process acceptable.

04 Behind old goods lies a service chain

For an old item to become a product again, a series of tasks must be completed.

Based on a typical business process, the secondhand industry chain can be divided into the following stages, though the exact combination varies by category and operating model:

Transaction Process

StageCore WorkValue to Both Parties
Recycling and ConsolidationReceive personal idle items, consignment items, or trade-in returned goodsAllow dispersed supply sources to enter circulation channels
Authentication and GradingVerify authenticity, functions, condition, and repair statusMake the product status describable and comparable
Refurbishment and PricingCleaning, necessary repairs, and pricing based on condition and demandImprove usability and form a pricing basis
Warehousing and SalesInventory management, channel distribution, display, and deliveryHelp products find suitable buyers
After-sales and RecirculationHandle returns, repairs, and subsequent recyclingClarify responsibilities and support re-circulation

The price consumers see on the shelf includes the cost of these tasks.

But the challenges differ by category. Digital devices require assessment of performance, repair history, and data security; secondhand bags require verification of authenticity and condition; clothing requires solving cleaning, sizing, and try-on issues; books require balancing unit value against handling and transportation costs.

Therefore, operating experience in one product category cannot be directly copied to all secondhand categories. A product must not only be needed by someone, but also be able to be sorted, delivered, and supported after sale at a reasonable cost in order to provide a basis for sustainable operation.

In the electronics sector, the relevant basic rules have gradually become more specific.

The Standard for Grading the Usability of Secondhand Electronic Products (GB/T 45656—2025) was issued and implemented on April 25, 2025, providing a national-standard basis for product grading. The exact timing is subject to the National Public Service Platform for Standards Information.

Another task takes place where consumers cannot see it: removing information from old devices.

An interpretation released by the Cyberspace Administration of China on the Data Security Technology Requirements for Information Erasure of Electronic Products makes clear that this mandatory national standard will take effect on January 1, 2027, covering requirements such as information erasure, effectiveness verification, and operation records.

This means that the services provided by recycling operators must answer not only whether the device can still be used, but also whether the previous user’s information has been properly handled.

Policy attention also goes beyond simply “collecting old goods.” The expert interpretation of the Circular Economy Development 15th Five-Year Plan, released by the National Development and Reform Commission on July 3, 2026, discusses standardizing the secondhand goods circulation and trading market alongside improving the recycling network.

From an industry perspective, one key capability of scaled operations is turning a large volume of products in different conditions into inventory with relatively complete information that can be graded and matched to demand.

The products are still different, but the processes for inspection, description, information handling, and delivery can be more orderly.

05 The larger the market, the more it matters to look at circulation efficiency

Data released by the Ministry of Commerce show that China’s secondhand goods transaction volume reached 1.69 trillion yuan in 2024, up 28% year on year.

The size of the market shows that transaction demand has already formed, but whether operators can make a profit still depends on more specific questions.

How long does it take for collected goods to be sold? How much do inspection and cleaning cost? Can items still be sold smoothly after returns? If a product stays in the warehouse for one more month, will the price change?

For the buyout model, inventory ties up capital and price declines compress profit; for the consignment model, even if the operator has not paid the purchase price upfront, they still bear storage, display, communication, and order-processing costs.

Corporate financial data provide a concrete window for observation.

Aihuishou disclosed that in the second quarter of 2026, revenue was approximately 6.609 billion yuan, up 32.4% year on year; fulfillment expenses in the same period were approximately 542 million yuan, operating profit under U.S. GAAP was approximately 178 million yuan, and adjusted operating profit was approximately 206 million yuan.

These figures belong to one company and one quarter, and cannot represent the profit level of the entire secondhand industry; adjusted profit also cannot be mixed with U.S. GAAP figures. What they show is that while transaction scale is growing, delivery and operating expenses still have to be paid in real money.

The difference between the buyback price and the selling price cannot be directly regarded as profit. Logistics, refurbishment, rent, labor, after-sales service, and inventory losses all need to be covered by operating revenue.

Offline stores and branded clustered districts can provide conditions for viewing goods, experiencing products, and making side-by-side comparisons; online channels can expand the range of supply-demand matching. How the two work together should ultimately come down to whether goods are easier to sell and whether overall costs can be controlled.

Therefore, more worth tracking than store count and the number of items collected are four indicators: the time from intake to sale, the processing and fulfillment cost per item, return and after-sales costs, and whether buyers and sellers use the service again.

Collecting a lot but selling slowly creates inventory pressure; selling cheaply but without protection also makes it hard to build trust over time.

06 Insight view

When secondhand stores enter malls, more consumers may compare pre-owned goods while shopping for new products, and selling unused items may become a more convenient everyday service. Whether this change in setting can generate sustained demand depends on whether stores can connect in-person experience with back-end inspection, pricing, and after-sales service.

For malls, what is worth watching is transaction volume and repeat visits after the opening buzz fades; for operators, it is necessary to distinguish the processing cost, turnover speed, and return reasons of each category. If new stores expand supply and buyer coverage but also lengthen inventory holding time, scale growth may not lead to better operating results. Consumers, meanwhile, need to be able to understand product condition and know clearly who is responsible if problems arise.

Current store cases, specialized surveys, and the performance of a single company are still not enough to prove that all secondhand categories are suitable for large-store operations. A more testable direction is to keep reducing information gaps, waiting time, and the cost of handling disputes while expanding coverage.

07 Conclusion

Secondhand stores entering shopping malls make the process of an old item being chosen again more visible.

For consumers, it expands the room for budget allocation and product selection, while also providing a new destination for idle items. For the industry, every successful transaction requires recycling, appraisal, pricing, delivery, and after-sales service to work together.

How far this market can go depends on whether the experience on both ends can improve at the same time: buyers can more easily judge whether it is worth it, and sellers can more conveniently realize reasonable value.

Helping old items find their next user, while also giving both sides fewer concerns and more certainty, is the foundation for the continued growth of the secondhand industry.

DJyanbao
Author
DJyanbao covers all investment sectors comprehensively, with extensive macroeconomic, industry, and listed company research. It uses advanced technologies including intelligent search engines, professional OCR, document structuring analysis, and natural language processing to provide convenient, comprehensive, real-time, professional info retrieval for financial investors, corporate executives, consultants, industry researchers, market analysts, and operations personnel. Committed to cutting-edge tech and user-friendly experiences, it helps professionals and investors efficiently extract value from vast information.
Best Selling
Trends in 2026
Customizable Products
— Please rate this article —
  • Very Poor
  • Poor
  • Good
  • Very Good
  • Excellent